Choosing the right siding for your home is an important decision that impacts not only your home’s appearance but also its durability and value. For Chicago homeowners, the debate often boils down to Hardie board vs vinyl siding. Let's explore the differences between these two popular options, comparing materials, quality, appearance, and cost to help you make an informed decision.
What is the Difference Between Hardie Board Siding and Vinyl Siding?
1. Material
What is Hardie Board Siding Made Of?
Hardie board siding, also known as Hardie plank or fiber cement siding, is made from a mixture of cement, sand, and cellulose fibers. This composition gives it remarkable durability and resistance to various environmental factors.
The materials used in Hardie board house siding are designed to withstand extreme weather conditions, making it an excellent choice for homes in Chicago where the weather can be quite harsh. Unlike other materials, fiber cement siding doesn’t expand or contract with temperature changes, ensuring a stable installation when you hire a knowledgeable and experienced team.
What is Vinyl Siding Made Of?
Vinyl siding is made from polyvinyl chloride (PVC), a type of plastic. It’s manufactured by melting the PVC and forming it into long, thin sheets. These sheets are then cut into the desired shapes and textures to mimic the appearance of wood or other materials. Vinyl siding is lightweight and easy to install, which contributes to its popularity among homeowners looking for a cost-effective siding option. Despite its benefits, vinyl siding can become brittle in extremely cold weather, potentially leading to cracks and breaks.
2. Quality
Hardie Board Siding Quality
When it comes to quality, Hardie board siding stands out due to its durability and longevity. It’s resistant to fire, pests, and rot, making it a reliable choice for long-term home protection.
Hardie board also has a high resistance to impact damage, which is a significant advantage in areas prone to severe weather conditions. The robust nature of this material ensures that your home remains protected for decades, with minimal maintenance required. Additionally, Hardie board is often backed by long-term warranties, providing further assurance of its quality and performance.
Vinyl Siding Quality
Vinyl siding is known for its affordability and ease of maintenance. However, it doesn’t offer the same level of durability as Hardie board. Vinyl can crack or warp under extreme temperatures, and it’s more susceptible to impact damage. While it’s resistant to moisture and doesn’t rot, it can fade over time when exposed to direct sunlight. This makes it less ideal for areas with extreme weather variations. Although vinyl siding can be a practical choice for homeowners on a budget, it may require more frequent repairs and replacements over time.
3. Appearance
What Does Hardie Board Siding Look Like?
Hardie board siding is highly versatile in terms of appearance. It can be manufactured to mimic the look of traditional wood, shingles, or even stucco, providing a wide range of aesthetic options. The types of Hardie board siding include smooth, textured, and wood-grain finishes, allowing homeowners to achieve the exact look they desire.
The paint used in Hardie board is baked on, which helps it maintain its vibrant color for many years. This versatility makes Hardie board a popular choice for those seeking a high-end, customizable look.
What Does Vinyl Siding Look Like?
Vinyl siding also offers a variety of styles and colors, mimicking the look of wood, cedar, and other materials. However, its appearance can sometimes look less authentic compared to Hardie board.
The texture and finish of vinyl can appear more artificial, especially upon close inspection. While there are many design options available, vinyl siding does not offer the same high-end look that Hardie board can provide. Despite this, vinyl siding can still effectively enhance a home’s exterior, particularly when the goal is to achieve a clean, uniform appearance on a budget.
4. Cost
How Much Does Hardie Board Siding Cost?
The cost of Hardie plank siding is generally higher than vinyl. On average, homeowners can expect to pay around $12 per square foot for materials and installation.
This cost reflects the high-quality materials and the labor-intensive installation process. However, the investment in Hardie board can pay off in the long run due to its durability and low maintenance requirements. Over time, the reduced need for repairs and replacements can offset the initial higher cost, making it a cost-effective option for long-term homeowners.
How Much Does Vinyl Siding Cost?
Vinyl siding is more budget-friendly, typically costing between $3 to $7 per square foot, including installation. This lower cost makes it an attractive option for homeowners looking to save money upfront. However, it’s essential to consider the long-term costs associated with maintenance and potential repairs, as vinyl siding may not last as long or provide the same level of protection as Hardie board. The lower initial cost can be appealing, but the need for more frequent replacements can make it less economical in the long run.
Is Hardie Board Worth the Extra Cost?
Is Hardie Plank Siding Better Than Vinyl?
Hardie plank vs vinyl siding comparisons often highlight the superior durability and longevity of Hardie board. While vinyl siding is less expensive and easier to install, Hardie board offers better protection against fire, pests, and weather damage.
For homeowners willing to invest in their property’s long-term value and aesthetic appeal, Hardie board is often considered the better choice. The enhanced durability and resistance to environmental factors make Hardie board a more robust and reliable option for homeowners.
Which is Better, Hardie Board or Vinyl Siding?
When deciding between Hardie board vs vinyl siding, it’s essential to consider your specific needs and budget. Hardie board provides superior durability, a longer lifespan, and a more authentic appearance, making it ideal for homeowners looking for a high-quality, long-term solution.
On the other hand, vinyl siding is more affordable and easier to install, which might be preferable for those with budget constraints or who plan to sell their home in the near future. Ultimately, the decision comes down to weighing the initial cost against the long-term benefits and maintenance requirements.
What are the Negatives of Hardie Board Siding?
While Hardie board siding offers many benefits, it’s not without its downsides. The primary disadvantage is the higher cost compared to vinyl siding. Additionally, Hardie board is heavier and more challenging to install, which can increase labor costs. It also requires painting over time, although far less frequently than wood siding.
Despite these drawbacks, many homeowners find that the benefits outweigh the negatives, especially in terms of durability and appearance. The need for periodic maintenance and potentially higher installation costs are important factors to consider when choosing Hardie board.
Can I Replace My Vinyl Siding with Hardie Board?
Yes, replacing vinyl siding with Hardie board is a viable option for homeowners looking to upgrade their home’s exterior. This process involves removing the existing vinyl siding and installing Hardie board in its place. While this can be a more costly endeavor, the improved durability, appearance, and value of Hardie board make it a worthwhile investment for many homeowners. The transition from vinyl to Hardie board can significantly enhance the home’s curb appeal and structural integrity.
Do I Need a James Hardie Preferred Installer for Hardie Board Siding in Chicago?
It’s highly recommended to use a James Hardie Preferred Installer for your Hardie board siding installation in Chicago. These professionals are trained and certified by James Hardie to ensure that the siding is installed correctly and to the manufacturer’s specifications.
Proper installation is crucial for maximizing the longevity and performance of Hardie board siding. Hiring a preferred installer also provides peace of mind, knowing that your investment is protected by warranties and the expertise of a skilled professional. Working with a certified installer ensures that your siding project is completed efficiently and to the highest standards.
Hardie Board vs Vinyl Siding: The Verdict
When comparing Hardie board vs vinyl siding, Hardie board offers superior durability, a longer lifespan, and greater aesthetic versatility, making it an excellent choice for Chicago homeowners willing to invest in their property’s future.
While vinyl siding remains a popular and cost-effective option, the long-term benefits of Hardie board siding make it a compelling choice for those looking to enhance their home’s protection, curb appeal, and value. Smardbuild is Chicagoland's go-to exterior home remodeler and a James Hardie Preferred installation expert. We're here for all of your questions about James Hardie and other exterior remodeling questions, so contact us to set up a quick consultation. We can't wait to hear from you!
